Compare · AI writing tools
Open Atelier and Sudowrite
Sudowrite is built around AI that writes: it drafts, rewrites, describes, expands and brainstorms, with a story bible feeding the model and a choice of models behind it. Open Atelier starts from the other end. It reads your chapters, finds craft problems and teaches the fix, with no AI needed. AI is a choice per manuscript: none, a reader that only leaves notes, or suggestions that go in only when you accept them, each recorded as AI generated.
Choose Sudowrite if
- You want AI to draft whole scenes or chapters from an outline.
- You want to choose between many models, including Sudowrite's own.
- You want AI brainstorming, chat and plugins as your main way of working.
- You want AI developmental edits, line edits and beta reads.
Choose Open Atelier if
- You want to write the book yourself and get better at it, with lessons tied to your own pages.
- You want feedback that runs without AI, free, and a re-check that shows what your revision changed.
- You want a manuscript where no model is ever called, or where AI reads but never writes.
- You want a record of which passages you typed and which came from AI.
At a glance
| Feature | Sudowrite | Open Atelier |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | SudowriteYesIn the browser, with mobile apps. | Open AtelierYesIn the browser, on a computer or a phone. Nothing to install. |
| How you pay | SudowriteYesFrom $10 a month, with a monthly allowance of AI credits. A free trial with no card. | Open AtelierYesFree plan, unlimited for everything that calls no model. Atelier is $21 a month or $189 a year. |
| Organising a long book | SudowriteYesOutline, scenes and draft, canvas, series. | Open AtelierYesParts, chapters and scenes, with a plan board, an outline and scene cards. |
| Story bible | SudowriteYesFeeds the AI; entries can be hidden from it. | Open AtelierYesCharacters, places, facts over time and relationships, with names marked on the page as you write. |
| AI that writes text | SudowriteYesWrite, rewrite, describe, expand, brainstorm, chat and first drafts. | Open AtelierIn partOnly in Co-write mode, and only when you accept a suggestion. Coach mode reads and never writes. |
| Choice of AI model | SudowriteYesIts own Muse model and models from Anthropic, OpenAI and Google. | Open AtelierNoOne model, Claude Sonnet 5.5, included in the plan. No keys to bring. |
| Writing with no AI at all | SudowriteNoAI is the product. | Open AtelierYesHuman only mode, per manuscript: no model is ever called, enforced on the server. |
| Feedback on your writing | SudowriteYesAI feedback; higher plans add AI developmental and line edits. | Open AtelierYesA rule-based chapter check for dialogue, continuity, point of view, prose and scenes, free and with no AI. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5. |
| Lessons tied to your pages | SudowriteNo | Open AtelierYes14 lessons. A finding opens the lesson for it, then an exercise on your own passage, then a re-check. |
| Your writing kept out of AI training | SudowriteYesSudowrite's FAQ says it does not use your writing to train AI models. | Open AtelierYesNever, in any mode. Model calls are made with retention turned off. |
| A record of how text was written | SudowriteNo | Open AtelierYesEach passage is recorded as typed, pasted, imported, AI generated or AI modified. A record, not proof. |
| Export | SudowriteYesWord, and PDF. | Open AtelierYesWord in standard manuscript format, EPUB, PDF, Markdown and text, plus a full backup. |
Different starting points
For some writers. Sudowrite is for writing with AI: it can draft a scene from beats and rewrite a paragraph many ways. Open Atelier is for writing yourself and improving: its core is a check on your chapter, a lesson for each finding, an exercise on your own passage and a re-check. Co-write mode does offer rewrites, continuations and drafted beats, but nothing enters the manuscript until you accept it, and accepted text is recorded as AI generated.
Feedback without a model
In Open Atelier, yes. The chapter check is rule-based: it looks for dialogue tag habits, adverbs on tags, long speeches, names spelled two ways, filtered point of view, clutter, echoes, stock phrases and backstory. It runs free, in every mode, and never calls a model. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5 on scenes, characters and pacing, which never touch the manuscript.
Being truthful about how a book was written
Open Atelier records every passage as typed, pasted, imported, AI generated or AI modified, and editing AI text never turns it back into typed. The authorship record shows each source's share for the book and each chapter, and can go with a Word export as an appendix. It is a record, not proof: anyone can retype text.
Moving from Sudowrite
Yes. Sudowrite's project export is a zip of Word files, and Open Atelier imports it in your browser, one chapter or more per file. Imported text is recorded as imported, since Open Atelier cannot know how it was written before.
Check a page of your own
Paste a page from your manuscript and see what the check finds. It runs in your browser, sends nothing and uses no AI.
Other comparisons
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Scrivener
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Microsoft Word
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Google Docs
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Dabble
- AI writing toolsOpen Atelier and Novelcrafter
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and ProWritingAid
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and AutoCrit