Compare · Writing software
Open Atelier and Google Docs
Google Docs is free, runs everywhere and makes writing with other people effortless: share a link and edit together. It is a general document editor, so a novel is one long file or a folder of them, and its suggestions stop at spelling and grammar. Open Atelier is made for a book and its writer: a chapter check for fiction habits, a lesson for each finding, a story bible and a record of how each passage was written.
Choose Google Docs if
- You write with a co-author or editor in the same document at the same time.
- You want comments and suggested edits from many people on one file.
- You want everything free, with no plan at all.
- You write all sorts of documents and want one tool for them.
Choose Open Atelier if
- You want feedback on fiction craft: dialogue, point of view, continuity, prose habits and scenes.
- You want your book as parts, chapters and scenes, not one long file.
- You want a story bible that knows your characters and marks them on the page.
- You want AI off for a manuscript, guaranteed on the server, or AI that only reads.
At a glance
| Feature | Google Docs | Open Atelier |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | Google DocsYesIn the browser, and apps for Android and iPhone. | Open AtelierYesIn the browser, on a computer or a phone. Nothing to install. |
| How you pay | Google DocsYesFree with a Google account. Gemini in Docs needs a paid Google plan. | Open AtelierYesFree plan, unlimited for everything that calls no model. Atelier is $21 a month or $189 a year. |
| Organising a long book | Google DocsIn partHeadings and an outline of them; no scenes or cards. | Open AtelierYesParts, chapters and scenes, with a plan board, an outline and scene cards. |
| Story bible | Google DocsNo | Open AtelierYesCharacters, places, facts over time and relationships, with names marked on the page as you write. |
| Version history | Google DocsYes | Open AtelierYesEvery chapter keeps its versions, with a view of what changed. |
| Writing with others | Google DocsYesReal-time co-editing, comments and suggested edits. | Open AtelierIn partReading links let readers react to paragraphs. No co-editing. |
| Grammar and spelling | Google DocsYes | Open AtelierNoNo grammar checker of its own. Your browser's spell check works in the editor. |
| Feedback on fiction craft | Google DocsNo | Open AtelierYesA rule-based chapter check for dialogue, continuity, point of view, prose and scenes, free and with no AI. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5. |
| Lessons tied to your pages | Google DocsNo | Open AtelierYes14 lessons. A finding opens the lesson for it, then an exercise on your own passage, then a re-check. |
| AI that writes text | Google DocsYesGemini drafts and rewrites on paid plans. | Open AtelierIn partOnly in Co-write mode, and only when you accept a suggestion. Coach mode reads and never writes. |
| Your writing kept out of AI training | Google DocsYesGoogle says Gemini in Docs does not use your content to train generative AI models. | Open AtelierYesNever, in any mode. Model calls are made with retention turned off. |
| A record of how text was written | Google DocsNo | Open AtelierYesEach passage is recorded as typed, pasted, imported, AI generated or AI modified. A record, not proof. |
Where Google Docs is the better choice
If you write with someone else, Google Docs is hard to beat. Two people can type in the same chapter at once, comments thread beside the text and suggested edits can be accepted one by one. It costs nothing and opens on any device. Open Atelier has no co-editing; its reading links let readers react to paragraphs, but only you edit the book.
What a fiction writer gives up in Docs
Docs sees text, not a story. It does not know a scene from a chapter, who your characters are, or that a name has been spelled two ways. Its suggestions are about spelling and grammar.
Open Atelier checks each chapter for the habits that weaken fiction, anchors each finding to your words and opens a short lesson, then an exercise on your passage, then a re-check. The story bible marks names on the page, and the plan shows every scene in the book.
Moving a book from Google Docs
Download the document as Word (.docx) from Docs, then import it in Open Atelier. Headings become chapters and italics and bold are kept. Several files can be imported at once, one chapter or more per file. The file is read in your browser and only the text you keep is sent.
Check a page of your own
Paste a page from your manuscript and see what the check finds. It runs in your browser, sends nothing and uses no AI.
Other comparisons
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Scrivener
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Microsoft Word
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Dabble
- AI writing toolsOpen Atelier and Sudowrite
- AI writing toolsOpen Atelier and Novelcrafter
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and ProWritingAid
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and AutoCrit