Compare · AI writing tools
Open Atelier and Novelcrafter
Novelcrafter is a web app for planning and writing novels, with a detailed codex and AI features that run on a model you connect: your own key with OpenAI or OpenRouter, or a local model. Open Atelier includes one model in its plans, so there are no keys or token bills, and its core needs no model at all: a chapter check, a lesson for each finding and a re-check. Each manuscript chooses how much AI it allows.
Choose Novelcrafter if
- You want to pick your own model, including local models running on your machine.
- You already pay a model provider and want to use that account.
- You want a codex with progressions and mention tracking at the centre of your planning.
- You want a low-cost plan for writing without AI.
Choose Open Atelier if
- You want AI included in the price, with no keys and no token maths.
- You want feedback on your chapters that needs no model, and lessons on what it finds.
- You want to write when the connection drops, with edits saved when it returns.
- You want export to EPUB and PDF as well as Word, and a record of how each passage was written.
At a glance
| Feature | Novelcrafter | Open Atelier |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | NovelcrafterYesIn the browser, installable as a browser app. | Open AtelierYesIn the browser, on a computer or a phone. Nothing to install. |
| How you pay | NovelcrafterYesFrom $4 a month, with a 21-day trial. No free plan. | Open AtelierYesFree plan, unlimited for everything that calls no model. Atelier is $21 a month or $189 a year. |
| Organising a long book | NovelcrafterYesActs, chapters and scenes, with grid, matrix and outline views. | Open AtelierYesParts, chapters and scenes, with a plan board, an outline and scene cards. |
| Story bible | NovelcrafterYesThe codex: aliases, relations, progressions and mention tracking. | Open AtelierYesCharacters, places, facts over time and relationships, with names marked on the page as you write. |
| Version history | NovelcrafterYesRevision history with restore. | Open AtelierYesEvery chapter keeps its versions, with a view of what changed. |
| Export | NovelcrafterIn partWord and Markdown. | Open AtelierYesWord in standard manuscript format, EPUB, PDF, Markdown and text, plus a full backup. |
| Works offline | NovelcrafterNoNovelcrafter says it needs an active internet connection. | Open AtelierIn partTyping never waits on the network and edits made offline save when you reconnect, but the app opens online. |
| AI included | NovelcrafterNoYou connect your own model; Novelcrafter provides none. | Open AtelierYesClaude Sonnet 5.5, paid for by the plan. |
| Choice of AI model | NovelcrafterYesOpenRouter, OpenAI, local models through Ollama or LM Studio, and others. | Open AtelierNoOne model, Claude Sonnet 5.5, included in the plan. No keys to bring. |
| Feedback on your writing | NovelcrafterIn partStatistics such as word counts and an appearance heatmap. | Open AtelierYesA rule-based chapter check for dialogue, continuity, point of view, prose and scenes, free and with no AI. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5. |
| Lessons tied to your pages | NovelcrafterNo | Open AtelierYes14 lessons. A finding opens the lesson for it, then an exercise on your own passage, then a re-check. |
| Your writing kept out of AI training | NovelcrafterYesIts privacy policy says users' novels are never used to train AI. | Open AtelierYesNever, in any mode. Model calls are made with retention turned off. |
| A record of how text was written | NovelcrafterNo | Open AtelierYesEach passage is recorded as typed, pasted, imported, AI generated or AI modified. A record, not proof. |
Bring your own model, or have one included
No. Novelcrafter leaves the model to you: you connect a provider such as OpenAI or OpenRouter with your own key, or run a local model. That gives you full choice and puts the cost on your provider's bill. Open Atelier has no bring-your-own-key: its plans include Claude Sonnet 5.5, and the free plan includes a few Coach reads and Co-write requests each month.
Feedback that needs no model
Yes. The chapter check is rule-based and free in every mode: dialogue tags and adverbs, long speeches, names spelled two ways, filtered point of view, tense and person shifts, clutter, echoes, stock phrases and backstory. Each finding opens a lesson and an exercise on your passage, then a re-check. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5 that never enter the manuscript.
Moving from Novelcrafter
Yes. Open Atelier reads Novelcrafter's novel export, as Markdown or Word, in your browser. Codex folders become story bible entries; snippets and chats are left out. Imported text is recorded as imported.
Check a page of your own
Paste a page from your manuscript and see what the check finds. It runs in your browser, sends nothing and uses no AI.
Other comparisons
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Scrivener
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Microsoft Word
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Google Docs
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Dabble
- AI writing toolsOpen Atelier and Sudowrite
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and ProWritingAid
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and AutoCrit