Compare · Editing and feedback software
Open Atelier and AutoCrit
AutoCrit is a web platform for fiction writers with more than 20 editing reports, from adverbs and word choice to pacing and dialogue, genre comparisons, AI beta readers and an academy. Open Atelier shares the idea that feedback should be about fiction, and builds a loop around it: each finding opens the lesson for that problem and an exercise on that passage, then a re-check shows what changed. Every manuscript chooses its AI mode, and the record shows how each passage was written.
Choose AutoCrit if
- You want your manuscript compared with published books in your genre.
- You want AI beta readers and a story analysis of the whole book.
- You want live sessions and courses alongside the tool.
- You want AI inspiration tools for ideas and drafting.
Choose Open Atelier if
- You want each finding to lead straight to a lesson, an exercise on your passage and a re-check.
- You want continuity checks against your own story bible.
- You want a manuscript where no model is ever called, enforced on the server.
- You want a record of which passages you typed and which came from AI.
At a glance
| Feature | AutoCrit | Open Atelier |
|---|---|---|
| Where it runs | AutoCritYesIn the browser; desktop recommended. | Open AtelierYesIn the browser, on a computer or a phone. Nothing to install. |
| How you pay | AutoCritYesA free plan with a few reports, and a Pro subscription. | Open AtelierYesFree plan, unlimited for everything that calls no model. Atelier is $21 a month or $189 a year. |
| Organising a long book | AutoCritYesNoteboards and cards, and a story builder with beat sheets. | Open AtelierYesParts, chapters and scenes, with a plan board, an outline and scene cards. |
| Story bible | AutoCritYesStory builder for worldbuilding and characters. | Open AtelierYesCharacters, places, facts over time and relationships, with names marked on the page as you write. |
| Fiction editing reports | AutoCritYes20+ reports, from adverbs and word choice to pacing and dialogue; AutoCrit says they are algorithmic. | Open AtelierYesA rule-based chapter check for dialogue, continuity, point of view, prose and scenes, free and with no AI. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5. |
| Comparison with published books | AutoCritYesGenre comparison on Pro. | Open AtelierNoThresholds are tuned against published prose, but there is no genre comparison. |
| AI beta readers | AutoCritYesAI alpha and beta readers and a story analyser, on Pro. | Open AtelierIn partCoach mode: notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5 on a chapter, and Ask the book. |
| Lessons tied to your pages | AutoCritIn partAn academy and live sessions, alongside the reports. | Open AtelierYes14 lessons. A finding opens the lesson for it, then an exercise on your own passage, then a re-check. |
| AI that writes text | AutoCritYesGenerative AI in its Inspiration Studio. | Open AtelierIn partOnly in Co-write mode, and only when you accept a suggestion. Coach mode reads and never writes. |
| Your writing kept out of AI training | AutoCritYesAutoCrit's FAQ says your writing does not train its AI. | Open AtelierYesNever, in any mode. Model calls are made with retention turned off. |
| A record of how text was written | AutoCritNo | Open AtelierYesEach passage is recorded as typed, pasted, imported, AI generated or AI modified. A record, not proof. |
| Export | AutoCritYesEPUB and print PDF formatting on Pro. | Open AtelierYesWord in standard manuscript format, EPUB, PDF, Markdown and text, plus a full backup. |
Two fiction-first feedback tools
Both read fiction as fiction. AutoCrit gives you a wide set of reports and compares your book with others in its genre. Open Atelier gives fewer, tighter checks and spends its effort on what happens next: each finding opens the one lesson section that answers it, then an exercise on that passage in the chapter itself, then a re-check that shows whether the habit is gone.
AI, by manuscript
Yes. Human only is a mode per manuscript, enforced on the server: no model is called by any route. The chapter check, lessons, story bible, plan, export and record all work in it, free. Coach adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5 that never touch the manuscript, and Co-write offers suggestions that go in only when you accept them.
Moving from AutoCrit
Export your manuscript as Word or text and import it in Open Atelier. Headings become chapters, italics and bold are kept, and the file is read in your browser.
Check a page of your own
Paste a page from your manuscript and see what the check finds. It runs in your browser, sends nothing and uses no AI.
Other comparisons
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Scrivener
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Microsoft Word
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Google Docs
- Writing softwareOpen Atelier and Dabble
- AI writing toolsOpen Atelier and Sudowrite
- AI writing toolsOpen Atelier and Novelcrafter
- Editing and feedback softwareOpen Atelier and ProWritingAid