All comparisons

Compare · Editing and feedback software

Open Atelier and ProWritingAid

ProWritingAid is a grammar and style checker with more than 25 reports, from passive voice and overused words to dialogue and pacing, and it works inside Word, Google Docs, Scrivener and your browser. Open Atelier is a place to write the book: a manuscript editor with a story bible and plan, a chapter check for fiction habits, and for each finding a lesson and an exercise on your own passage, then a re-check.

Choose ProWritingAid if

  • You want grammar, spelling and style checks inside the editor you already use.
  • You want many reports at once, including readability and sentence length.
  • You want quick rephrasing suggestions as you edit.
  • You want a lifetime licence.

Choose Open Atelier if

  • You want an editor built for a novel, with chapters, scenes, a story bible and a plan.
  • You want each finding to open a lesson and an exercise on that passage, then a re-check.
  • You want continuity checks against your own story bible, such as a name spelled two ways.
  • You want the core of it free and unlimited, with no word limit on checks.

At a glance

Where it runsProWritingAidYesA web editor, desktop apps, browser extensions and add-ins for Word, Google Docs and Scrivener.Open AtelierYesIn the browser, on a computer or a phone. Nothing to install.
How you payProWritingAidYesFree up to 500 words a check. Premium from $120 a year, or a lifetime licence.Open AtelierYesFree plan, unlimited for everything that calls no model. Atelier is $21 a month or $189 a year.
A manuscript editorProWritingAidIn partIts own web editor; not a book organiser.Open AtelierYesParts, chapters and scenes, with a plan board, an outline and scene cards.
Story bibleProWritingAidNoOpen AtelierYesCharacters, places, facts over time and relationships, with names marked on the page as you write.
Grammar and spellingProWritingAidYesOpen AtelierNoNo grammar checker of its own. Your browser's spell check works in the editor.
Style and craft reportsProWritingAidYes25+ reports, including style, overused words, sticky sentences, dialogue, pacing and clichés.Open AtelierYesA rule-based chapter check for dialogue, continuity, point of view, prose and scenes, free and with no AI. Coach mode adds notes from Claude Sonnet 5.5.
Continuity against your storyProWritingAidNoOpen AtelierYesNames spelled two ways, and characters named after they leave or die.
Lessons tied to your pagesProWritingAidIn partExplanations with each suggestion, and workshops on Premium Pro.Open AtelierYes14 lessons. A finding opens the lesson for it, then an exercise on your own passage, then a re-check.
AI that writes textProWritingAidYesRephrase and Sparks generate short rewrites, with daily limits.Open AtelierIn partOnly in Co-write mode, and only when you accept a suggestion. Coach mode reads and never writes.
Turning AI offProWritingAidYesIts generative features can be switched off.Open AtelierYesHuman only mode, per manuscript: no model is ever called, enforced on the server.
Your writing kept out of AI trainingProWritingAidYesProWritingAid says it never uses your text to train its algorithms.Open AtelierYesNever, in any mode. Model calls are made with retention turned off.
A record of how text was writtenProWritingAidNoOpen AtelierYesEach passage is recorded as typed, pasted, imported, AI generated or AI modified. A record, not proof.

A checker or a place to write

They overlap on feedback and differ on everything around it. ProWritingAid goes to your text wherever it lives and checks grammar as well as style. Open Atelier is where the book lives: parts, chapters and scenes, a story bible, version history, export and a record of how each passage was written. It does not check grammar.

From finding to fix

In Open Atelier, a finding is the start of a short loop. It opens the lesson section for that exact problem, with before-and-after examples and a note on when to keep the habit. Practice dims the rest of the chapter and checks your passage as you revise. Done runs the check again and shows your own words then and now. If you keep the habit on purpose, you say why and it stays out of later checks.

Using both

Yes. A common way is to write and revise for craft in Open Atelier, then export to Word and run a final grammar pass in a checker of your choice.

Check a page of your own

Paste a page from your manuscript and see what the check finds. It runs in your browser, sends nothing and uses no AI.

Try it on your chapter
Runs in your browser. Nothing you paste is sent. No AI.Tuned on published novels, so good prose draws few flags.

Other comparisons